Education Policy and the U.S. Presidential Election
United States presidential campaigns have a history of centring K-12 education policy—something that has been markedly missing from both the Democratic and Republican platforms for the 2024 election. The Biden administration has focused much of its energy on post-secondary policy, offering student loan forgiveness of up to $20,000 USD for qualifying Americans. Platforms emphasizing K-12 reforms—such as George W. Bush’s No Child Left Behind and Barack Obama’s Race to the Top—seem to have been left in the past.
Kamala Harris has left the Biden education initiatives largely untouched. The official Democratic platform makes a promise to “provide free, universal preschool for four-year olds,” but gives no insight as to how this goal will be funded. Further ambitious K-12 plans are included in the platform, such as “providing intensive tutoring; extending the school day and school year; expanding community schools; … [and improving] working conditions and support to help make teaching a sustainable and affordable profession”. Despite these commitments made by the party, the issue of education has rarely come up in presidential debates or public forums. When K-12 education does come to the forefront, it is often in a highly politicized manner.
President Trump has repeatedly proposed the elimination of “critical race theory” and the promotion of gender transition from schools. Although he is attempting to distance himself from the controversial Project 2025, a policy agenda put forth by prominent right wing advocates at and former Trump administration officials at the Heritage Foundation, President Trump’s official platform repeats many of its education goals. The stance of both Project 2025 and the official Republican platform is that the Department of Education should be abolished entirely, returning all power over K-12 schooling to the states.
Trump’s education policies will likely reflect the moves conservatives have been making to reshape public schools and their curriculums recently. Between July and December of 2022, Texas schools banned 438 books, Florida schools banned 356, Missouri schools 315, and Utah and South Carolina schools over 100 each. In this time period, 13 school districts in Florida, a state won by Trump in the 2020 election, banned books. Conservatives have been targeting books that discuss violence and physical abuse, mental health, death, racism, LGBT issues, and sex.
In May of 2023, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed into law HB 1069, including provisions requiring that “instruction and course material […] shall: [teach] the benefits of monogamous heterosexual marriage” and school districts “shall adopt and publish on its website the process for a parent to limit his or her student’s access to materials in the school or classroom library.” Republican politicians such as DeSantis, in line with Project 2025’s goals, support limiting the materials taught in classrooms across the United States. Despite this seeming commitment to changing the way American K-12 education operates, government officials have yet to outline clear plans for education reform on the federal level.
Although both platforms call for drastic changes within the United States education system, Trump’s and Harris’s plans remain vague and rarely discussed on the national stage. While social issues—such as the teaching of gender and race related topics—in schools are repeatedly brought up by both parties, education policy in terms of funding, teacher supports, and social programs to support students have fallen into the background.
Edited by Idan Miller
Featured Image: “The Lyndon B. Johnson Building, headquarters of the United States Department of Education” by Coolcaesar is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
